Overcoming the “Overhead Myth” with New Financial Reporting Requirements

By John D'Amico  |  February 26, 2019

Have you heard of the Overhead Myth campaign, started in 2013 by Better Business Bureau’s Wise Giving Alliance, Charity Navigator and GuideStar®? Its aim is to change the practice of judging a nonprofit’s performance solely on its overhead ratio to a more balanced view that takes into account a range of other factors, including transparency, governance, leadership and results.

As a reminder, overhead ratio is the percentage of a nonprofit organization’s expenses that are spent on administrative (commonly called management & general) and fundraising costs, collectively called “supporting services.” It is calculated by adding administrative and fundraising costs and dividing by total expenses.

Until now, nonprofits were only required to report their expenses by functional category on their financial statements (Program, Management & General, Fundraising) and not by the well-known business categories of expenses (salaries, occupancy costs, interest, depreciation, etc.), the so called “natural categories”. The only way to determine what a nonprofit’s expenses were comprised of was by accessing their IRS Form 990. However, the new financial reporting requirements for nonprofits as promulgated by FASB’s Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2016-14 will now require all nonprofits to report their expenses by both function and by natural category, all in one place on their financial statements. This will enable nonprofits to better tell their financial stories, as readers of their financial statements (including donors) will now see the types of expenses that make up the organization’s program, administrative and fundraising costs.

In our opinion, this is a welcome change and one that adds value through common sense expense reporting. Charities are encouraged to go a step further and include a thorough discussion of all their programs in their annual financial statements and on IRS Form 990. This enables a fuller understanding of what the charity is doing and what they are trying to accomplish, and helps donors make well-informed decisions on how a charity is performing rather than relying on justify the overhead ratio. A real win-win.

For more information, visit the organizations involved with the Overhead Myth campaign:  

www.give.org for information on BBB Wise Giving Alliance. 
www.guidestar.org/update to learn about the free GuideStar Nonprofit Profiles. 
www.charitynavigator.org to find out more about their star-rating charity evaluations.

This blog post is excerpted from, “The “Overhead Myth” – Finding Better Ways to Judge Nonprofit Performance” by John D’Amico, which originally appeared in the Q3 issue of Marks Paneth’s Nonprofit and Government Times. Click here to read the full article.

SUCCESS IS PERSONAL Click here to learn more about our brand

About John D'Amico

John D'Amico, CPA, is a Partner within the Professional Standards Group at Marks Paneth LLP, which is responsible for monitoring quality control in the firm as mandated by professional standards. He specializes in pre-issuance reviews and inspections of nonprofit organizations, governments and Single Audits. Mr. D’Amico also provides consultation on accounting and attestation matters and tests and monitors the firm's quality review policies and procedures. He teaches continuing education classes for the firm and on... READ MORE +


Upcoming Events

New York Multifamily Summit Online Conference

October 1, 2020
New York Multifamily Summit Online Conference

5th Annual Nonprofit Industry Update Seminar

October 7, 2020

Executive Spotlight: Assess the Financial Health of your Organization with Data Science


Global Tax Rule Changes

October 15, 2020

2020 Accounting & Finance Show

October 20, 2020

National Women in Commercial Real Estate Finance & Development Forum

October 29, 2020
View All Events